F6EXV’s Blog

Comments and thoughts about the DX scene

Selling cards

Hello !

My attention was called upon by a spot on the cluster system today about C91VM and his QSL demands. See by yourself at qrz.com for that call.

For years I have modestly been trying to fight this trend of selling cards one way or the other, but this time, enough is enough.

Several times, both IOTA and DXCC people have told me that they could not do anything against it. WRONG : When there is a will…

It is very simple to say : XXyXX’s QSLing practices have proven against the ethics of ham radio, and his operation is disqualified from our program.

How can one DEMAND 5 USD for a card, even under the background of a humanitarian operation ?

I can speak about this as I was working for the UNHCR in Rwanda and Zaire back in 1994/1995, and did some operating while there on duty, operating 9X5DX then 9Q5EXV. So tell me about humanitarian operations ! I risked my life there : I was there when the genocide happened in Rwanda, I was caught under shelling for several days, and so on. But that is not the point.

I have no objection if any ham radio operation advertises for a humanitarian cause or suggests that a donation is welcome. I have a BIG problem when QQSLing is linked to a compulsory donation, whichever amount is demanded. There is no other name to this than “selling a card”.

By definition included in the rules of both the IOTA program and the DXCC program, this practice is UNETHICAL and MUST void the validity of the operation for these respective awards.

Sorry, but “sorry we cannot do anything” is no longer an excuse.

Cowardness to face this issue is leading to more and more QSL business, that a true operator must condemn strongly.

No more time for words, time for action. INTEGRITY is at stake !

73 de F6EXV

Advertisements

October 7, 2009 - Posted by | Uncategorized

3 Comments »

  1. Haven’t been to Mozambique since the days of FRELIMO, MANU and UNAMI. Well, with international pressure, they got what they wanted. Now they want humanitarian aid? A good start would be to remove the AK-47 from their flag (and the accompanying attitude).

    Personally, I have no problem with anyone asking $5 for a QSL card. I do, however, have a problem with someone paying the $5.

    73, Bob.

    Comment by Bob Furzer | October 7, 2009 | Reply

  2. Hi,
    I saw that he was active yesterday and also went to qrz.com to see the information about his station.
    Here i also got the shock about asking $5 for his QSL card.
    Would be ok as he would be asking $2….and then if we want to give more..we could.

    Just my opinion.

    Comment by Bernard PD7BZ | October 8, 2009 | Reply

  3. Just to add to the same thing, 1st time experienced from the andaman operation, the demanded only on QSL pr. envelope and $ pr. card. The other stn never got his card inspite of more than nessary postage for both in the same envelope. They just kept the extra money.
    I have also sent I dont know how many cards to BV stn for a phone confirmation, both direct and via buro, no response what so ever. And I am not putting any extra money above the 2 us$,
    China same thing, worked a guy in China, going on several locations, sent cards, no response. Same rule above 2$ no way, if I want to donate I do it on my free will, and the amount I will.
    I am not pleased at all.

    LA5YJ, Hugo
    ex 9N7YJ, ST2YJ, XU7ACW, JW5YJ, S21XF & MI0YJR

    Comment by Hugo | December 7, 2010 | Reply


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: